Comparing 5 Whiskies: Jameson Black Barrel, Monkey Shoulder, The Balvenie Stories, Isle of Raasay, Aberfeldy 12 Year Old

Hey there! Are you a fan of whiskey and looking to add some new bottles to your collection? Well, you’re in luck because today we’re going to be taking a closer look at some fantastic options. Whether you’re an Irish whiskey lover, a Scotch whisky connoisseur, or just someone wanting to explore the world of fine spirits, we’ve got something for everyone. So sit back, relax, and let’s dive in!

Whiskey, or whisky depending on where it’s made, has a rich history dating back centuries. Both Irish whiskey and Scotch whisky have their own unique traditions and production methods, resulting in distinct flavors and characteristics. Owning a bottle of Jameson Black Barrel Blended Irish Whiskey would be a delightful addition to your bar. This blend is aged in double charred bourbon barrels, lending it a rich and robust flavor profile with notes of vanilla, spice, and toasted oak. Plus, it comes beautifully packaged in a gift box, making it a perfect present for whiskey enthusiasts.

Moving on to Scotch whisky, Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky is a must-try. Made from a combination of three different Speyside single malts, this whisky offers a smooth and creamy taste with hints of honey, vanilla, and spices. Its name pays homage to the traditional maltsters who used to manually turn the malted barley with a shovel, and today, Monkey Shoulder continues this heritage by hand-selecting and marrying whiskies to create their unique blend. It’s a versatile whisky that can be enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or in your favorite cocktail.

If you’re feeling adventurous and want to explore a more unique flavor profile, The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky is the perfect choice. Crafted at The Balvenie Distillery, this whisky is heavily influenced by the traditional use of peat in the production process. It has a distinct smokiness that intertwines with notes of honey, citrus, and oak. Each bottle tells a story of the craftsmen involved in its creation, adding an extra layer of charm to this already exceptional whisky.

For something truly special and limited edition, Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky is a true gem. This distillery special release has been matured in sherry casks, resulting in a rich and fruity flavor profile. With a higher ABV of 52%, this whisky packs a punch and showcases the craftsmanship of the Raasay Distillery. It’s a rare find that will undoubtedly impress both whisky connoisseurs and collectors alike.

Last but certainly not least, let’s talk about Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky. This whisky exudes elegance with its golden gift tin and sophisticated taste. Aged in oak casks, it boasts flavors of honey, fruits, spices, and a hint of smoke. Aberfeldy is known for using only the finest ingredients and traditional production methods, resulting in a single malt whisky that embodies the true essence of the Highlands.

So, there you have it – a brief introduction to these remarkable whiskies. The world of whiskey is vast and varied, offering something for every palate and preference. Whether you’re looking for an Irish whiskey with a twist like Jameson Black Barrel, a smooth and versatile Scotch whisky like Monkey Shoulder, or a unique and limited-edition bottle like the Isle of Raasay, there’s a whiskey out there just waiting to be discovered by you. Sit back, pour yourself a dram, and enjoy the journey!

Jameson Black Barrel Irish Whiskey 70 cl with Gift Box

• Versatile and can be enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails

• Unique blend of pot still and grain whiskeys for a rich and sweet taste

• Triple distilled for a refined flavor

• Maturation in oak, sherry, and ‘Black’ barrels adds depth and complexity

• Comes with a gift box, making it an ideal gift option

• The taste may be too sweet for some individuals who prefer a drier whiskey profile

With its versatile usage options, exceptional blend of pot still and grain whiskeys, and high-quality craftsmanship, Jameson Black Barrel Blended Irish Whiskey is a fantastic choice for whiskey enthusiasts. Whether you enjoy it neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails, this whiskey will impress you with its rich, smooth, and sweet taste. Its award-winning reputation and stylish gift box make it a perfect choice for special occasions or as a thoughtful gift for loved ones.

Monkey Shoulder Scotch Whisky (70cl)

Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky is a versatile spirit that is suitable for various occasions. Whether you prefer enjoying it neat, on the rocks, or as part of a delightful cocktail, this whisky is designed to provide a rich, smooth, and fruity taste experience.

We are big fans of Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky for several reasons. Firstly, its distinct flavor profile offers a unique combination of malty sweetness, barley sugar, and hints of marmalade. These flavors create a delightful sensory experience that is both satisfying and unforgettable.

Additionally, the nose of this whisky is characterized by zesty orange notes with a hint of honey and delicate vanilla. These aromas add depth and complexity to each sip, making it a pleasure to savor and enjoy.

Another reason we like this product is its exceptional quality. It is made using a closely guarded recipe that blends several Speyside single malt scotch whiskies. This meticulous blending process results in a well-balanced and flavorsome whisky that is loved by whisky enthusiasts around the world.

Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky is crafted with the intention of providing whisky lovers with a unique and enjoyable drinking experience. The whisky is matured in first-fill ex-Bourbon casks and blended in small batches for up to 6 months. This process allows the flavors to develop and harmonize, resulting in a smoother and richer taste.

One of the key features of this whisky is its versatility. Whether you prefer your whisky in a classic Old Fashioned, a contemporary Espresso Martini, or a refreshing Monkey Colada, this spirit enhances the flavors of your chosen cocktail, adding a bold yet balanced smoothness, malty character, and fruity notes.

However, Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky can also be enjoyed neat. Adding a few ice cubes to a glass with a generous pour of this whisky allows you to fully appreciate its intricate flavors and aromas. The rich and complex profile shines through, creating a truly enjoyable drinking experience.

The overall quality of Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky is exceptional. This whisky has gained recognition and numerous accolades from prestigious spirits competitions around the world. It has been awarded Gold medals at the International Wine & Spirits Challenge in both 2022 and the International Spirits Challenge from 2016 to 2021. These honors are a testament to the craftsmanship and dedication that goes into producing this outstanding whisky.

Pros:

• Rich, smooth, and fruity taste
• Versatile for both neat sipping and mixing in cocktails
• Distinctive zesty orange and delicate vanilla aromas
• Small-batch production process for enhanced flavor
• Multi-award-winning whisky

Cons:

• Some may find the price point slightly higher compared to other blended whiskies

Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky is a highly enjoyable spirit that offers a range of flavors and aromas to satisfy whisky enthusiasts. Its rich and smooth taste, along with its versatility for mixing cocktails or sipping neat, makes it a favorite among whisky lovers worldwide. With its exceptional quality and numerous awards, Monkey Shoulder is definitely a whisky worth exploring and adding to your collection.

The Balvenie Stories Peat 17 Year Old Scotch Whisky, 70cl

The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky is primarily used for savoring and enjoying the complex flavors of a well-crafted whisky. It is perfect for whisky enthusiasts and connoisseurs who appreciate the intricacies of a peat-smoked single malt.

We love The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky for its exceptional taste and the unique story it tells. Its fusion of gentle sweet peat smoke, floral notes, and butterscotch honey creates a harmonious flavor profile that is both intricate and satisfying. The velvety and round taste, balanced with citrus flavors, oaky vanilla, and blossom honey, is an experience to be savored.

The purpose of The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky is to provide whisky enthusiasts with an exceptional and memorable tasting experience. Crafted from homegrown barley and produced using traditional crafting methods, The Balvenie showcases the dedication to quality and craftsmanship that sets it apart from other single malts.

Some key features of this whisky include its gentle sweet peat smoke, lighter floral notes, and delicate butterscotch honey on the nose. Upon tasting, one can expect a velvety and round flavor profile, where the peat smoke perfectly balances the citrus flavors, oaky vanilla, and blossom honey. The finish offers a delightful lingering and creamy vanilla sweetness with a touch of gentle smoke.

The overall quality of The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky is truly exceptional. The use of homegrown barley and the adherence to traditional crafting methods ensure a whisky of unparalleled quality and taste. The expertly balanced flavors and the smoothness of this 17-year-old single malt make it a standout choice for whisky enthusiasts seeking a premium drinking experience.

Pros:

• Exceptional taste with a harmonious blend of flavors
• Crafted using homegrown barley and traditional methods
• Smooth and velvety texture
• 17 years of maturation adds depth and complexity
• Lingering and creamy vanilla sweetness in the finish

Cons:

• May be considered pricier compared to some other whisky options
• Peat smoke flavor may not appeal to those who prefer non-peated whiskies

The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky is a remarkable choice for whisky enthusiasts who appreciate the art of peat-smoked single malts. Its exceptional taste, unique story, and commitment to traditional craftsmanship make it a standout option in the whisky market. While it may be pricier and the peat smoke flavor may not suit everyone’s preferences, those who appreciate the complex flavors and smoothness of this whisky will find it truly remarkable.

Raasay Distillery Special Release Single Malt Scotch Whisky

The Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Distillery Special Release is a limited edition annual whisky release that showcases the distillery’s commitment to innovation and pushing the boundaries of flavor. It is meant to provide whisky enthusiasts with a unique tasting experience that deviates from the distillery’s signature style.

We love the Isle of Raasay Distillery Special Release for its small-batch, handcrafted approach to whisky making. The careful maturation process, starting in ex-rye whiskey casks and finishing in ex-Pedro Ximénez and Oloroso sherry quarter whisky casks, results in a truly exceptional flavor profile. The combination of peppery spice, almond, nuts, sweet fruit, floral notes, and hints of nutmeg and clove creates a multi-dimensional and enjoyable drinking experience.

The purpose of the Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Distillery Special Release is to offer whisky enthusiasts a taste of something different and unique. As the first legal spirit from Raasay, an island with a rich history of illicit distilling, this whisky pays homage to traditions while embracing contemporary thinking. Its unique provenance, inspired by Raasay’s geology and water source, is highlighted in both the creation and bottle design.

Key Features of this special release include its limited quantity, with each bottle being produced in small batches. The whisky is distilled, matured, and bottled entirely at the Raasay Distillery, ensuring a hands-on and artisanal approach. Its flavor profile, combining the richness of sherry cask aging with the complexity of rye whiskey cask maturation, sets it apart from other whiskies.

The Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Distillery Special Release boasts outstanding quality in every aspect. From the carefully selected casks to the meticulous distilling and bottling process, no detail is overlooked. The flavor profile is well-balanced and nuanced, offering a range of flavors that complement each other harmoniously. The dedication to craftsmanship and innovation is evident, making this whisky truly exceptional.

• Limited edition release for a unique tasting experience

• Small-batch, handcrafted production for exceptional quality

• Rich flavor profile with a combination of sherry and rye whiskey cask influence

• Unique provenance and bottle design inspired by Raasay’s history and environment

• Limited availability due to the annual release nature

• May not suit those who prefer lighter and less complex whiskies

The Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Distillery Special Release is a highly recommended addition to any whisky enthusiast’s collection. Its limited edition status and exceptional flavor profile make it a must-try for those seeking a unique and handcrafted whisky experience. The combination of traditional techniques and contemporary thinking sets it apart from other whiskies, making it a standout option for discerning palates.

Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky – Gold Gift Tin, Oak-aged, Honey, Fruit, Spices, Vanilla & Smoke, 40% ABV, 70cl / 700ml

The Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky is primarily used for enjoying its smooth and easy-drinking taste. It can be savored neat, over ice, or even mixed in a cocktail like the Aberfeldy Gold Fashioned.

We love the Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Whisky because it offers a classic fruity Highland style and is carefully crafted to perfection. Its rare honeyed notes, combined with hints of fruit, spices, vanilla, and a touch of smoke, create a unique and enjoyable drinking experience. Plus, it comes in a stunning gold gift tin, making it a perfect gift for any whisky lover.

The Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Whisky is known as ‘The Golden Dram’ for a reason. It is a single malt Scotch whisky that has been aged for 12 years in fine oak casks. This aging process brings out its distinct honeyed flavor, giving it a smooth and delectable taste.

The whisky is produced in the foothills of the Central Highlands of Scotland at the Aberfeldy distillery, which was founded in 1898 by the Dewar brothers, Tommy and John Alexander. The distillery’s long-standing expertise in whisky-making is evident in the exceptional quality of Aberfeldy whiskies.

Key features of the Aberfeldy 12 Year Old include its syrupy texture, luscious notes of vanilla and fudge, and a subtle touch of smoke on the finish. Its well-balanced combination of flavors makes it a versatile whisky that can be enjoyed on its own or in cocktails.

The overall quality of the Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Whisky is exceptional. Its smoothness and richness make it a standout choice among whisky enthusiasts. The carefully selected oak casks and meticulous aging process result in a whisky that is both delightful and complex. The numerous gold medals awarded to Aberfeldy further testify to its high quality and excellence.

Pros:

• Deliciously smooth and easy-drinking
• Rare honeyed notes and fruity flavors
• Syrupy with hints of vanilla and fudge
• Versatile, can be enjoyed neat, over ice or mixed in a cocktail
• Comes in a stunning gold gift tin, perfect for gifting

Cons:

• May not be suitable for those who prefer peaty or heavily smoky whiskies

The Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky is a remarkable whisky that stands out for its smoothness, honeyed notes, and an array of delightful flavors. Whether you are a whisky lover or looking for a special gift, this whisky is sure to please with its exceptional quality and extraordinary taste. Cheers to experiencing ‘The Golden Dram’!

Comparison of Specifications

Jameson Black Barrel Blended Irish Whiskey with Gift box, 70 cl

• Blend of traditional Irish pot still and rare small batch grain whiskeys
• Triple distilled with a rich, smooth and sweet taste (40% vol)
• Matured in a combination of oak, sherry and double charred ‘Black’ barrels
• Winner of the 2019 San Francisco World Spritis Competition (SFWSC) Double Gold medal

Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky, 70cl

• Rich, smooth, and fruity taste with hints of malty sweetness, barley sugar and marmalade
• Zesty orange, slightly honeyed with light and delicate vanilla notes on the nose
• Blend of Speyside single malt scotch whiskies
• Matured in first-fill ex-Bourbon casks and blended in small batches
• Multi-Award Winning

The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 70cl

• Made from home grown barley and crafted in a traditional way
• Nose: Gentle sweet peat smoke, lighter floral notes and delicate butterscotch honey
• Velvety and round to taste with peat smoke balancing citrus flavors, oaky vanilla and blossom honey
• Exclusive annual Scotch whisky release
• Unique among single malts

Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Distillery Special Release | 52% ABV, 70 CL

• Matured first in ex-rye whiskey casks and finished in a combination of sherry quarter whisky casks
• Hints of peppery spice, almond, nuts and sweet fruit with floral notes along with nutmeg and clove
• Distilled and bottled at Raasay Distillery
• First legal spirit from Raasay
• Unique water source and geology inspired the creation and bottle design

Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky with Gold Gift Tin, 40% ABV, 70cl / 700ml

• Carefully crafted and matured in fine oak casks
• Known for its rare honeyed notes and spice, with a hint of smoke on the finish
• Distilled in the foothills of the Central Highlands of Scotland since 1898
• Over 150 gold medals awarded
• Best served neat, over ice or mixed in a cocktail

Specifications Comparison Table

Product	Whiskey Type	Distillation Process	Maturation Process	Awards
Jameson Black Barrel Blended Irish Whiskey with Gift Box, 70 cl	Blended Irish Whiskey	Triple distilled	Oak, sherry, and double charred ‘Black’ barrels	2019 SFWSC Double Gold medal
Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky, 70cl	Blended Malt Scotch Whisky	Blend of Speyside malts	First-fill ex-Bourbon casks, blended in small batches	Gold, International Wine & Spirits Challenge 2022; Gold, International Spirits Challenge 2022; Distiller of the Year, International Spirits Challenge 2016-2021
The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 70cl	Single Malt Scotch Whisky	Traditional crafting methods	Home grown barley, peat smoke, citrus flavors, vanilla sweetness	–
Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Distillery Special Release, 70cl	Single Malt Scotch Whisky	Traditional and specialty	Ex-rye whiskey casks, sherry quarter whisky casks	–
Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky with Gold Gift Tin, 40% ABV	Single Malt Scotch Whisky	Traditional	Fine oak casks	Over 150 gold medals

Conclusion

Jameson Black Barrel Blended Irish Whiskey with Gift box, 70 cl

In summary, the Jameson Black Barrel Blended Irish Whiskey is a fantastic choice for whiskey lovers. Its smooth and rich flavor, combined with the elegant gift box, makes it a perfect gift for any occasion. However, some may find the price a bit high compared to other options on the market.

Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whisky, 70cl

If you’re a fan of blended malt scotch whisky, the Monkey Shoulder is a must-try. With its unique combination of flavors and smoothness, it offers a delightful drinking experience. The only drawback is that some may find it a bit too expensive for regular consumption.

The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 70cl

For those seeking a peaty and smoky single malt scotch whisky, The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat 17 Year Old is an excellent choice. Its distinctive flavors and well-rounded taste make it a treat for whisky enthusiasts. However, the limited availability and higher price tag may not make it suitable for everyone.

Isle of Raasay Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Distillery Special Release | 52% ABV, 70 CL | Limited Edition Scotch Whisky – Sherry Cask Finished | Distilled, Matured and Bottled at Raasay Distillery |

If you’re looking for a unique and limited-edition scotch whisky, the Isle of Raasay Special Release is worth considering. Its sherry cask finish adds depth and complexity to the whiskey’s flavor profile. However, the higher alcohol content may not be suitable for those who prefer milder spirits.

Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky with Gold Gift Tin, Aged in Oak Casks, Notes of Honey, Fruit, Spices, Vanilla & Hint of Smoke, 40% ABV, 70cl / 700ml

Finally, the Aberfeldy 12 Year Old Highland Scotch Single Malt Whisky is a wonderful choice for those who appreciate a balanced and flavorful whisky. With its notes of honey, fruit, spices, and a hint of smoke, it offers a complex and enjoyable drinking experience. The attractive gold gift tin also makes it a great option for special occasions. However, some may find the price a bit steep compared to other whiskies in this category.

Overall, each of these whiskies has its merits and drawbacks. If you’re a fan of Irish whiskey, the Jameson Black Barrel is recommended. For blended malt scotch whisky enthusiasts, the Monkey Shoulder is a safe bet. Those seeking a peaty and smoky whisky should try The Balvenie Stories Week of Peat. If you’re looking for a limited-edition option, the Isle of Raasay Special Release is worth considering. And for a well-balanced and flavorful scotch whisky, the Aberfeldy 12 Year Old is recommended. Cheers!

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.